Tammys Pizza

Reviews

• Jen K.

  star star star star star 5 June 2026

  Excellent pizza.  Bomb.  Deliciousness.  Homemade.  In the top for my favorite pizzas in Columbus!  I get the pep and cheese and I most recently tried their baked ravioli.  It was very good as well!
  
  I've also had a chef salad and I really enjoyed the toppings--packet dressings FYI.
  
  Definitely a fan!

• Robert L.

  star star star star star_border 22 May 2026

  Revisit since I haven't been here in awhile, I'm alone on New Years and wanted some pizza.
  I think this is one of those locations that does not receive enough attention. They are always clean and take care of me when I visit. The pizza reminds me of high school but Tammy's is a thin crust, a large pepperoni I bought for lunch after percussion practice three times a week but the owner closed it and pursued another business so this pizza brings back memories, also made me realize how everything is more expensive as you grow old.
  But this place is very nice, clean, takes a little longer to bake but worth it.
  My only complaint is buying extra sauce on the side, the sauce is watered down. Not flavorful.

• Christopher G.

  star star star star star_border 19 May 2026

  Ive had them like 4 or 5 times now, and its solid pizza. Not the best pie in C'bus, but way better than average. Fresh high quality ingredients, including old world pep, killer Italian sausage, and REAL aged provolone (not mozzarella!) which gives this pie a great and unique tastes.
  
  Ive never eaten in at this location, but they do have a small indoor seating area. Pie is always ready on time, and service is generally good, with one caveat...the owner likes to hire high school girls (see pic), and they can be a little ditsy at times, but I have always caught their mistakes, thus, never had a wrong order.
  
  Subs are A-OK too.
  
  And remember, there are 2 locations...this one on Hoover, and another on Broadway...make sure you call the right one!
  
  Sorry, no pix from me on this one. :(

• Erin T.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 19 May 2026

  On our way out of town we stopped by for a late lunch.  Walking in the smell of sour milk hit me like a ton of bricks.  We walked up to the counter and ordered an Italian Sub to share and a pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms, and onions.  They stated it would be a 15 min wait and received our food after 25 mins.  The sub had more ham than any other toppings but was pretty good.  The pizza had the small pepperonis and was covered with cheese but did not look like it was baked long enough minus the pepperonis.  I could smell that sour milk scent while eating the pizza.  Must be how they store their cheese.  I wasn't fond of it at all.  My boyfriend thought it was alright but not enough to want to come back.  Overall disappointing.

• Jennie R.

  star star star star star_border 15 May 2026

  Picked up an Italian Sub and a Meatball sub for lunch after a little hike at Pleasant Valley. The subs were ready when I got there and the price seemed fair.